Dave's Fiction Warehouse

In which I bloviate about books, TV, movies, politics and other stuff I know little about..

  • Books
  • Movies
  • TV
  • politics
  • american life
  • Writing
  • Other Stuff

Connect

  • Email
  • Facebook

Powered by Genesis

It’s time for some token technology

October 16, 2012 by Dave Knadler

romney obama second debate

You want to take this outside?

After watching Candy Crowley struggling to wrangle the cats in tonight’s debate, I wondered: Why do we even need a moderator for these things?

Here’s my idea: Give each candidate a list of questions, and a certain number of tokens representing half of the available airtime for the debate. Each token activates the mike for precisely two minutes. When the time is up, the mike goes off. Then it’s the other guy’s turn.

This goes on, question by question, until the debate comes to an end. A particularly windy candidate can keep on talking past his two minutes, but nobody can hear him. Because the other guy has inserted a token and it’s his turn to talk.

It pretty clear by now that moderators don’t work, particularly in a pseudo “town hall” format where the candidates can wander the stage like ferrets, talking over each other and the hapless moderator while spraying rehearsed bullet points in answer to questions that have not been asked.

I hate it when the commentariat declares instant winners and losers for these things, since I don’t believe there’s reliable scoring system for anything other than style. Now that objective truth is no longer a factor, I guess it comes down to who makes the fewest verbal gaffes. I’ll let Twitter decide. In the meantime, I know who I’m voting for, and I suspect you do too. Those people in the town hall seats though: who in the hell are those folks?

More along these lines:

  • There will be blood
  • Who’s got a lighter?Who’s got a lighter?
  • Street-fighting man
  • When smart people get stupid
  • Pick your poison

Filed Under: politics

Comments

  1. Joan says

    October 16, 2012 at 11:32 pm

    Dave, I would love to see your idea in action!

  2. Renata Birkenbuel says

    October 16, 2012 at 11:39 pm

    Hey, Dave,
    Good suggestion because I’m appalled at how rude Romney was tonight in talking over the moderator and the President. It seems that the circus environment is upgraded, anyway, with every national debate.

    I, too, want to know who the hell those people are who fill the seats. How were they selected? I was impressed with many of the questions tonight, though, by the chosen “Undecideds” in the audience. They must’ve practiced.

    I wish that President Obama would’ve have talked more about the potential heavy environmental damage that the Keystone Pipeline could cause while creating a minimal number of jobs.

    Romney and his ilk wrote the book on bullying, disrespect, fact-twisting and obstructing our President Barack Obama on every turn instead of negotiating to create the best legislation possible. They make me sick.

    I’m debate-tired and rant-weary, so that’s all for now. Thanks for writing your blog.

    • Dave Knadler says

      October 17, 2012 at 10:36 am

      Yes, the questions weren’t bad. I’m glad somebody finally asked Romney how he’d be different from Bush.

  3. Deb says

    October 17, 2012 at 7:07 am

    That summed things up very nicely.

Recent posts

  • The cold, hard West
  • The talented Mr. Santos
  • Reich of fools
  • Mad about Harry
  • The Cartwrights
    stand their ground

Recent comments

  • John H. on The cold, hard West
  • Dave Knadler on The talented Mr. Santos
  • John H. on The talented Mr. Santos
  • John H. on Reich of fools
  • Erin on Reich of fools

FInd something

send dave cash

The obligatory PayPal donation button. Go ahead: Make my day.