Dave's Fiction Warehouse

In which I bloviate about books, TV, movies, politics and other stuff -- all without the aid of ChatGPT!

  • Books
  • Movies
  • TV
  • politics
  • american life
  • Writing
  • Other Stuff

Connect

  • Email
  • Facebook

Powered by Genesis

A reality show worth watching

June 7, 2011 by Dave Knadler

casey anthony

World's worst mom.

Here in Florida, as the hot weather gives way to really hot weather, most people are oblivious because they’re all indoors watching the Casey Anthony trial. At a dinner party over the weekend, it was all anyone talked about.

You may have heard of Casey Anthony. She’s the young mom accused of killing her young daughter in 2008 and then becoming ensnared in her own web of lies. The case has captured imaginations around here because all of the characters are white, middle-class and good-looking, and because the motive in the case appears to be nothing more complicated than pure evil. The TV coverage is live, and it’s gavel-to-gavel. You can even stream it on the Internet.

But like a lot of TV shows, this one is an acquired taste. When you first tune in, it seems a lot like every city council meeting you’ve ever seen, with guys in suits constantly interrupting each other or getting up to rummage through a box. Spend a couple of hours with the Anthony trial, and you realize that American justice is quite a bit less streamlined than it is made to appear in scripted courtroom dramas. My initial hope of seeing a tearful Anthony blurt out a full confession on the stand – well, apparently that kind of thing almost never happens.

Despite the glacial pace, It’s still interesting TV. For me, it’s instructive to compare this sensational trial to the O.J. Simpson trial in 1995. In both, attractive people are accused of horrific crimes, but elsewhere the contrast is startling.

belvin perry jr.

World's best judge.

For example, the judge in the Anthony case, Belvin Perry Jr., is everything Lance Ito was not: Decisive, brusque and surpassingly well-versed in the pertinent law. As slow as this trial seems to move, I hate to imagine how much worse it might be in Ito’s hands. During the Simpson trial, Ito seemed hypnotized by the limelight and let Johnny Cochran put on a musical with everything but the Rockettes. The result was a verdict that turned solely on race and remains a great joke at the expense of justice. Perry sees foolishness coming from a great distance, and shuts it down pronto. I’m not sure why he feels it’s necessary to run his own blog during the trial, but I’ll give him the benefit of the doubt on that.

Meantime, when in Florida … I’ll be tuning into to the live coverage from time to time, and rendering a verdict of my own. I have to say, at this point it’s not looking real good for Casey.

More along these lines:

  • downton abbey season 2 sceneGoing downhill at Downton Abbey
  • jax shooting sceneA shooting on Market Street
  • The blog about nothing much
  • Stabilize those death videos
  • cell phones in flightSimply gawking is no longer enough

Filed Under: Other Stuff, television

Comments

  1. Deanna Harms says

    June 7, 2011 at 10:28 pm

    David and I groan when every morning the Today Show turns to the Casey trial. You can set your clock by it. Why the nation is mesmerized by it, we can’t say. Like an accident, people find it hard to turn away. We find it hard to watch. Give us NPR.

    • Dave Knadler says

      June 8, 2011 at 8:46 am

      I felt much the same way — kind of how I feel about “American Idol” when I’ve missed the whole season. The trick is not allowing any of the details and back story to permeate.

      I imagine most people watch because they want this young woman to get what’s coming to her. Yes, it’s unseemly that people find this kind of thing entertaining, but it was ever thus.

Recent posts

  • Full frontal Florida
  • Later, alligator
  • A writer on top
    of the short-story game
  • ‘The Passenger’
    will please refrain
  • Floaters in the stream

Recent comments

  • John H. on Full frontal Florida
  • Rachel Kohl on Later, alligator
  • Dave Knadler on Later, alligator
  • John H. on Later, alligator
  • Dave Knadler on Later, alligator

FInd something

send dave cash

The obligatory PayPal donation button. Go ahead: Make my day.