Dave's Fiction Warehouse

In which I bloviate about books, TV, movies, politics and other stuff.

  • Books
  • Movies
  • TV
  • politics
  • Other Stuff
  • thatfuckingtrump

Connect

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Google+
  • Twitter

Powered by Genesis

An abrupt U-turn off "Damnation Street"

August 7, 2007 by Dave Knadler

I don’t know; maybe I’m really not such an aficionado of crime fiction. Occasionally, a well-reviewed book just hits me the wrong way, and I toss it aside about 40 pages in.

Such is the case with “Damnation Street” by Andrew Klavan. I picked it up at the library a couple of days ago, on the strength of his excellent 1997 thriller “True Crime.”

Where do I start with this book? First of all, the dopey conceit that this is a true story, starting with an author’s note that he personally knew both of the hardboiled protagonists, but will be inserting himself into the tale “only at those moments when I become and integral part of the narrative.” So right off, something I hate: a narrator who makes himself part of the story but also claims an omniscient point of view when it suits him. Must be nice to have it both ways. But it sure doesn’t do much for a reader’s suspension of disbelief.

Secondly, the characters. I understand Klavan has used them before, including “the Shadowman,” who is supposed to be the embodiment of evil — “the man has the eyes of a ghost” — but emerges as a plain-vanilla serial killer from central casting, distinguished only by an imaginative method of concealing a backup piece. The protagonists aren’t much better, two investigators supposed to represent yin and yang, the cerebral and the brutal, but neither displays more depth than one of those Roy Rogers cutouts.

And finally, the fulcrum of the plot: a hooker “with the face of angel.” You don’t see many of those in real life, and when you do they usually have the voice of Nancy Grace. I now call for a moratorium on the use of lovely prostitutes in crime fiction.

When I start a book I usually finish it, but this one outmatched my attention span early on. If anyone else has finished it and liked it, I’d be happy to entertain opposing views.

More along these lines:

  • "The Quickie" and the dead"The Quickie" and the dead
  • standing in another man's graveA detective and his devices
  • under the dome stephen kingHey, Steve. I’m back.
  • grant biography ron chernow historyIt could be worse.
    Just ask Grant
  • James Ellroy unleashed — and unfinishedJames Ellroy unleashed — and unfinished

Filed Under: Books

About Dave Knadler

Obscure writer. Lazy photographer. Bashful guitarist. Perhaps too fond of wine. Tireless nemesis of New York Times crosswords.

Comments

  1. Jessie Knadler says

    August 8, 2007 at 10:35 pm

    Thank you! I am SOO tired of the hooker/angel cliche. Wishful thinking on the part of male writers. If you’re going to go with the hooker angle, at least make her a brutal, shameless killer (of women not of men…just for something different); or make her so desensitized that she kills purely for kicks. An extracurricular activity between Johns.

Recent posts

  • Weather-beaten banner
  • Season of the witch
  • A good time for fiction
  • Bonfire of my vanity
  • It could be worse.
    Just ask Grant

Recent comments

  • Sarah Prodell on Weather-beaten banner
  • John H. on Weather-beaten banner
  • Joel Knadler on Weather-beaten banner
  • Joan M. Clauss on Weather-beaten banner
  • Susann on Weather-beaten banner

FInd something

send dave cash

The obligatory PayPal donation button. Go ahead: Make my day.